Paul Nicholls – Record Breaker

Hereford, December 1991. Paul Nicholls saddled his first winner as a National Hunt trainer when Olveston was successful. Fast forward almost 35 years and the 14-time Champion Trainer saddled Knappers Hill to win the Denis O’Connell Memorial Veterans’ Handicap Chase at Warwick, and in doing so, meant that Nicholls surpassed Martin Pipe as the most successful National Hunt trainer of all time, the 10-year-old being his 3,931st British winner of an illustrious career, which seems far from over.

by Paul Ferguson

Fittingly, Knappers Hill, who was partnered by a young Megan Nicholls when winning the Weatherbys-sponsored Grade 2 bumper at Aintree on Grand National day back in April 2021, carried the silks of the late Paul Barber, an integral part of Nicholls’ success.

From 10 winners during that first season (1991-92), Nicholls has built up one of the most outstanding training facilities either side of the Irish Sea, with his steep hill gallop one of the most iconic in the sport.

Numerically, 2020-21 was Nicholls’ most successful season, saddling 176 winners from 705 runners. 2016-17 yielded 171 winners, and in six of the seven seasons that he achieved 150+ winners, his strike rate remained between 25-27%.

Dan Skelton, Harry Fry and nephew Harry Derham have all come through the Ditcheat academy and are now leading trainers in their own rights. Ruby Walsh, synonymous with a ‘Golden Era’ for the stable, and Harry Cobden rode more winners for Nicholls than any other, although in total (to date), 11 jockeys have ridden 100+ winners for the stable, including another trio of current trainers, Christian Williams, Nick Scholfield and Sam Thomas.

Although a lot of the list is rather obvious, I have had to leave out several big names in my Top 10 Nicholls-trained horses, including Champion Chase winners, Call Equiname and Politologue, dual King George winner, Clan des Obeaux, Champion Hurdle winner, Rock On Ruby, and the ever-popular Frodon. Anyway, in reverse order, here we go:

10. STRONG FLOW

Probably the most left field selection, as injury sadly prevented him from realising his true potential, but winning a Hennessy after just four chase starts (and two runs over hurdles) as a novice was some performance. Rated 140, he had subsequent Grand National winner, Hedgehunter, 17 lengths away in fourth that day, despite conceding 10lb to him. Reverting to novice company, he won the Grade 1 Feltham (now the Kauto Star Novices’ Chase) next time but sadly never recaptured that form when returning from injury in 2005.

9. CYRNAME

Another who many wouldn’t have included in such a list. Whilst he lacked the consistency and longevity of several who could have featured, those three Ascot victories during 2019 were most taking. After winning a handicap by 21 lengths off a mark of 150, he slammed the current title holder, Waiting Patiently, in the Ascot Chase by 17 lengths, before returning from his summer break to end the lengthy winning run of Altior in the 1965 Chase. Never quite the same, he did win a Charlie Hall the following year, but will long be remembered for those three Ascot wins.

8. NEPTUNE COLLONGES

Somewhat overshadowed by stable-mates Denman and Kauto Star, the grey was a two-time Punchestown Gold Cup winner and won again in Ireland when landing Leopardstown’s Hennessy Gold Cup in February 2009. Fourth behind his aforementioned stable companions in the Gold Cup of that year, he was retired immediately after winning the 2012 Grand National, successful by a nose under Daryl Jacob.

7. SILVINIACO CONTI

A 29-length winner at Bangor-on-Dee on British debut, he won a brace of Grade 2 hurdles but as with many from the stable, surpassed any form over the smaller obstacles when sent chasing. Despite only winning twice as a novice, he went on to win seven Grade 1s in open company, including two Lancashire (Betfair) Chases, two King Georges and two Aintree Bowls. A flat track specialist, he built up a fine relationship with Noel Fehily.

6. SEE MORE BUSINESS

Carried out in the 1998 Gold Cup, he returned to win the blue riband event 12 months later, sporting first time blinkers. Another two-time King George winner, his victory in the 1999 Gold Cup was a hugely significant moment for Nicholls, as he began to elevate things to even greater heights after this, following the turn of the century.

5. AZERTYUIOP

Possibly higher up the list than many people would have him, he was a high-class hurdler who was electric as a novice chaser, unbeaten in four starts which culminated in an 11-length success in the Arkle. After unseating at the first fence in the Haldon Gold Cup (first start outside of novice company), he split Moscow Flyer and a former Nicholls inmate, Flagship Uberalles, in the Tingle Creek, before running a huge race in the Victor Chandler at Ascot, when he attempted to concede a huge 19lb to Isio in what was an epic duel. He won the Queen Mother Champion Chase that year (2004) and although he only raced for one more season and won twice more, he formed part of that unforgettable Tingle Creek of 2005, still one of my all-time favourite races.

4. MASTER MINDED

The ‘top four’ kind of picks itself and I wasn’t surprised to see the trainer nominate the same horses in a feature on the Racing Post website (posted today). After an inauspicious start to his British career at Exeter, he won a Sandown handicap chase in January 2008, slammed Voy Por Ustedes (winner of the 2006 Arkle and 2007 Champion Chase) in the Game Spirit before putting up what I still believe to be the single-best performance at a Cheltenham Festival in my lifetime. He confirmed the Newbury form by dethroning the title holder in the Queen Mother Champion Chase, at the tender age of five, which makes the performance all the more meritorious. He went unbeaten during a four-race campaign the following season, which included a second Champion Chase success, and despite probably not reaching those same lofty heights, he did go on to win another six races, including a rerouted (second) Tingle Creek and a Melling Chase over 2m4f at Aintree.

3. BIG BUCK’S

Whilst the other nine horses listed are renowned for their chasing exploits, he is the exception and by far the greatest hurdler to be trained in Ditcheat. A Graded hurdler in France, he was sent chasing as a four-year-old by Nicholls – something that was quite common at that time – and he won three times from six starts, seemingly relishing stepping up to a staying trip at Aintree. After unseating Sam Thomas at the last in the Hennessy on reappearance, he reverted to hurdles and won a Cheltenham handicap on New Year’s Day, beating subsequent Grand National winner, Don’t Push It, off a mark of 151 and conceding 16lb to the runner-up in the process. He then beat Punchestowns in the Cleeve and confirmed the form, despite meeting on 8lb worse terms, in the then-World Hurdle (since reverted back to the Stayers’ Hurdle), a race which he would win four times in all. He won 18 successive races and is one of the best staying hurdlers of the modern era.

2. DENMAN

A Grade 1-winning novice hurdler, he finished runner-up in the Baring Bingham at Cheltenham but developed into a top-class chaser, winning five from five as a novice. A winner of the Hennessy off 161 on his reappearance, his second season ended with a Gold Cup victory over stable-mate Kauto Star. Returning from a heart issue in the 2009 Hennessy, he put up an incredible performance to win a competitive handicap under top-weight and from the lofty mark of 174, giving 22lb to stable-mate What A Friend, who won Grade 1s on each of his next two starts. He never won another race, but that latest Newbury success remains one of the best races that I have witnessed live. The atmosphere was electric.

1. KAUTO STAR

The Kauto Star v Denman debate was one I always struggled with at the time. However, given his versatility in terms of distance and the longevity of his performances at the top level, top spot had to go to the French import. Another who endured a disappointment at Exeter during his first season in Britain (remounted after falling in a three-runner race, having looked a future star (pardon the pun) when beating Champion Hurdle 4th and subsequent Grade 1-winning novice chaser, Foreman, with ease at Newbury), he was beaten in the 2005 Haldon Gold Cup before winning the Tingle Creek.

A faller in the Queen Mother Champion Chase, it was the 2006-07 season when the son of Village Star emerged as one of the greatest chasers that we have ever seen. Having won the Old Roan (2m4f) at Aintree off a mark of 167, he stepped up in distance to win the Lancashire (Betfair) Chase at Haydock (3m) before dropping back to 2m to win a second Tingle Creek. Justifying odds-on favouritism in the King George (3m), he again made what was to become somewhat of a characteristic mistake at the last when winning the AON Chase (now the Denman Chase) before winning his first Gold Cup.

The following season, he attempted to concede a stone to Monet’s Garden in the Old Roan, won another Lancashire Chase, a second King George and an Ascot Chase (2m5f) before being beaten by Denman at Cheltenham and Our Vic in the Bowl at Aintree. He regained his Gold Cup crown in 2009 and in total won 16 Grade 1s, including five King Georges and four Lancashire Chases, and that ability to keep turning up at the very top level sets him apart.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Whether you agree or not, there is no denying that Nicholls has trained some all time greats and will, no doubt, be searching and hoping for the next one to emerge from his current crop at Manor Farm Stables. A quote placed on his website today reads “The fire is still burning as bright as ever and we haven’t started yet because for me, winning is an addiction.” He went on to state “First though I have the career total of 4,000 winners in my sights.”

During my annual pre-season visit to Nicholls’ yard, he was keen to show off his new schooling strip, which was due to be used for the very first time the following day, again highlighting his desire, and need, to move forward in his pursuit of more winners.

So, what of his current string. A trio of youngsters to note in the coming months include New Rules and Don’t Panic – a pair who won on the same Chepstow card in early-November – whilst River Kwai won an Exeter bumper last spring and has the size and scope to develop into a smart novice hurdler this season and an even better chaser in time.

On to the 4,000. And beyond.